What we will do for the famous

The other day I was reminded of the classic children’s story, “The Emperor’s New Clothes.”  It’s a Hans Christian Andersen tale about two weavers who swindle an emperor with a set of new clothes that are supposed to be completely invisible to anyone who is unfit for their position or stupid.  Everyone around the emperor, including he himself, pretends that they can see the invisible garments, for fear of being ‘outed’ as incompetent or dumb.  In actuality, though, they have all been taken advantage of because there is no substance to the clothes at all.  There is nothing there. In the end, when the emperor goes to display his new “clothes” to a crowd, only a small child is brave enough to speak up and say, “But he isn’t wearing anything at all!”

I was reminded of this classic story when I attended an author reading in Victoria the other night with a famous Canadian author. The presentation was eclectic, strange, weird, and very short. As I sat there amazed that someone this famous could get away with a presentation that was so sub-standard and uninspiring, I also wondered what other people in the room were thinking. Were they amazed and thrilled at this display of quirkiness which left me cold? It got me thinking how often we treat celebrities with too much awe.

Now don’t get me wrong, this writer is good. They do have talent which immediately puts them in a different category than someone who is famous just for being rich or pretty. But in this day and age, shouldn’t we expect a bit more? Someone was paying this person to be there to connect well with an audience of hundreds of people and inspire them to read using the words that they said and the image that they displayed. I think that ‘someone’ was shortchanged. And so were we all.

The truth of the matter is, we do judge a book by its cover. It’s not enough for only the words inside to be a great read. If the cover doesn’t inspire us to crack the book open and discover the beauty inside, we will have lost out on that beauty forever. Shouldn’t celebrities be the same? The other night I was not motivated to read this author’s new book simply because I lost almost all respect for the person themself when I saw them speak in public. I wondered how many other people felt the same, but yet still observed hundreds of people lining up to get the author’s signature at the end of the reading. Clearly, many in the room were more impressed by the scene that had unfolded than I. Or they didn’t care because the person was famous.

Is it too much to ask for the famous to rise to the challenge of their positions? Sure, I realize that they are just people too. But it is sad when you see someone in person that appears to be so revered and the little voice inside you just has the urge to shout: “But you gave us nothing at all!”

8 thoughts on “What we will do for the famous

  1. Disappointing but unfortunately it doesn’t surprise me. The last few times I’ve heard her on the radio I’ve found her egotism highly off-putting. Anyway, nicely said Beth!


  2. So I guess you might join my side and not buy her stuff anymore. All of her brilliance is going into her writing, which I find extremely dark and depressing, and none of it is going into her appearances. Personally I think that means she doesn’t care about her image and her writing is now only for herself and the almighty buck. She really doesn’t care what readers think. Off putting, to say the least.


    • It came on the heels of an absolutely amazing presentation a few months earlier by writer Philippa Gregory who was in town…now she’s a good speaker! Probably set the bar too high for those to follow. 🙂


  3. The trouble with writers doing public appearances is that they are talented with expressing themselves in writing and not by public speaking! The two don’t always go hand in hand.

    18 months ago we went on a coach trip in Wales led by a lady who had written a book about sacred sites in Wales. The trip was awful because she kept telling us to read her book if we wanted to know more. She just couldn’t put her self across in front of an audience the way she could on paper.

    BTW, hope you all had a fantastic Christmas.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s